The ultimate guide to selecting the best Xbox controllers for every gamer

We are currently in a golden age of gaming controllers, where the quality, versatility, and customizability have dramatically improved over past console generations. Gamers targeting Xbox Series X or Series S, and even Windows PC, have a variety of high-quality options from manufacturers like Microsoft, 8BitDo, PowerA, Razer, Scuf, Nacon, and Turtle Beach. Notably, some models now incorporate drift-proof Hall effect sticks, enhancing controller longevity and performance.

After extensive testing across multiple game genres such as first-person shooters, fighters, action-adventure, racing, and indie roguelikes, it becomes clear that the standard Xbox Wireless Controller is the most suitable option for the majority. It also serves as an excellent PC controller.

Key Features to Consider

Connectivity

Determining whether a controller is wireless and supports Bluetooth, or if it is wired only with a replaceable cable, is crucial for flexibility and ease of use.

Quality

The feel and durability of a controller, along with the absence of glitches or reliability issues, are important indicators of quality.

Extra features

Look for features such as remappable extra buttons or advanced triggers that enhance gameplay.

Customization

Assess if the controller allows button remapping, software profile adjustments, or has an aesthetically pleasing design.

Value

Consider whether the price of the controller reflects its features, making it affordable, average, or premium.

The Best Xbox Controller for Most People

Connectivity: Xbox wireless, Bluetooth, wired / Connector type: USB-C / Mappable rear buttons: No / Software customization: No / Power: AA batteries or rechargeables

The standard Xbox Wireless Controller is a remarkable all-rounder with more than 20 years of refinements. Its wireless connectivity is proprietary and unique among affordable controllers, though some dislike its reliance on AA batteries. Users can opt for rechargeable options, and it supports connection via USB-C.

The controller’s $60 price is justified by the excellent quality of its components — from its precise buttons to its satisfying, clicky D-pad. While it lacks additional features like customizable buttons or software tuning, Microsoft offers cosmetic options through their Xbox Design Lab.

The standard Xbox controller looks great, feels great, plays great, and is available in cool colors.

The Best Cheap Xbox Controller

Connectivity: Wired / Connector type: USB-C / Mappable rear buttons: Two / Software customization: No / Power: Wired

PowerA’s Advantage Wired Controller is a budget-friendly option at $37.99, sometimes selling for as low as $25. It features a detachable USB-C cable and hair-trigger lockouts, along with two customizable rear buttons. Despite its low price, it lacks Hall effect sticks, unlike the $40 GameSir G7 SE.

The rechargeable battery pack for gamers seeking alternatives to AA batteries.

The Best "Pro" Xbox Controller

Connectivity: Xbox wireless, Bluetooth, wired / Connector type: USB-C / Mappable rear buttons: Up to four / Software customization: Yes / Power: Built-in rechargeable

The Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 2 offers exceptional quality and features, including additional buttons, customizable settings, a built-in rechargeable battery, and superior build materials. The controller contains metallic touches and includes a charging dock. However, its $179.99 price may seem steep alongside its reputation for quality control irregularities.

The Xbox Elite Series 2 is made from premium materials but has a nice, subdued aesthetic.

A Formidable Alternative to the Elite

Connectivity: Wireless USB dongle (Xbox / PC), wired / Connector type: USB-C / Mappable rear buttons: Four / Software customization: Yes / Power: Built-in rechargeable

Razer's Wolverine V3 Pro is priced at $199.99, offering drift-free sticks, outstanding hair-trigger lockouts, and six remappable buttons with RGB lighting. However, it lacks Bluetooth and requires a USB dongle for wireless use, which might seem restrictive for some users.

The V3 Pro has four angled rear buttons and two extra shoulder buttons.

Other Controllers Worth Knowing About

• Nacon's Revolution X features extensive customization and great software.
• Turtle Beach offers audio-focused controllers like the Recon with useful features for competitive shooters.
• 8BitDo's Ultimate Wired Controller offers affordability and quality, now with Hall effect sticks available.
• Horipad Pro excels with a top-notch D-pad and ample customization at a low cost.
• Hyperkin Duke and other nostalgic models recreate classic Xbox gamepads for collectors.

Update, January 10th: Updated for 2025 with current pricing and availability.